| 1 | Academy of Notre Dame de Namur | Villanova, Pennsylvania | 22-1-0 | 1 | Inter-AC Champions, PAISAA Champions |
| 2 | The Episcopal Academy | Newtown Square, Pennsylvania | 19-3-0 | 2 | PAISAA Finalist |
| 3 | Emmaus High School | Emmaus, Pennsylvania | 27-1-0 | 8 | EPC Champions, District XI AAA Champions, AAA State Champions |
| 4 | Villa Maria Academy | Malvern, Pennsylvania | 22-3-0 | 3 | District 1 AAA Champions, AAA State Semifinalist |
| 5 | Oak Knoll School | Summit, New Jersey | 22-1-0 | 4 | Non-Public State Champions |
| 6 | Sacred Heart Academy | Louisville, Kentucky | 27-0-1 | 5 | KHSAA State Champions |
| 7 | Central Bucks West High School | Doylestown, Pennsylvania | 20-5-1 | NR | District 1 AAA Finalist, AAA State Finalist |
| 8 | New Trier High School | Winnetka, Illinois | 24-3-1 | 12 | Illinois State Champions |
| 9 | Trinity Episcopal Academy | Richmond, Virginia | 19-1-1 | 7 | LIS Champions, VISAA Division 1 Champions |
| 10 | Glenbrook North High School | Glenview, Illinois | 20-2-1 | 9 | Illinois State Finalist |
| 11 | The Hill School | Pottstown, Pennsylvania | 14-6-0 | 13 | MAPL Champions, PAISAA Semifinalist |
| 12 | West Essex High School | Caldwell, New Jersey | 20-5-0 | 14 | Group 2 State Champions |
| 13 | Collegiate School | Richmond, Virginia | 18-2-1 | 6 | LIS Finalist, VISAA Division 1 Finalist |
| 14 | Phillips Academy Andover | Andover, Massachusetts | 19-0-0 | 17 | NEPSAC A Champions |
| 15 | John Burroughs School | Saint Louis, Missouri | 26-1-0 | 18 | Missouri State Champions |
| 16 | Penn Manor High School | Millersville, Pennsylvania | 19-4-0 | 10 | Lancaster Lebanon League Champions, District 3 AAA Champions, AAA State Semifinalist |
| 17 | Palmyra Area High School | Palmyra, Pennsylvania | 23-3-0 | 16 | District 3 AA Champions, AA State Champions |
| 18 | The Agnes Irwin School | Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania | 15-5-0 | 21 | PAISAA Semifinalist |
| 19 | Darien High School | Darien, Connecticut | 18-2-1 | NR | FCIAC Champions, Class L State Champions |
| 20 | Staples High School | Westport, Connecticut | 20-2-0 | 15 | FCIAC Finalist, Class L State Finalist |
| 21 | Uxbridge High School | Uxbridge, Massachusetts | 23-0-0 | 20 | Division 3 State Champions |
| 22 | Mechanicsburg Area High School | Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania | 19-5-1 | 19 | District 3 AAA Finalist, AAA State Quarterfinalist |
| 23 | The Kinkaid School | Houston, Texas | 11-3-0 | 23 | SPC Champions |
| 24 | Lower Dauphin High School | Hummelstown, Pennsylvania | 17-5-1 | 11 | District 3 AAA 3rd Place, AAA State Quarterfinalist |
| 25 | Camden Catholic High School | Cherry Hill, New Jersey | 17-7-0 | 24 | Non-Public State Finalist |