| 1 | Sacred Heart Greenwich | Greenwich, Connecticut | 20-2-0 | 1 | NEPSAC A Champions, FAA Regular Season Champions, FAA Tournament Runner-Up |
| 2 | Lakeland High School | Shrub Oak, New York | 20-1-1 | 3 | NYS Class A State Champions |
| 3 | Greenwich Academy | Greenwich, Connecticut | 17-3-2 | 2 | NEPSAC A Quarterfinalist, FAA Tournament Champions |
| 4 | Maine-Endwell High School | Endwell, New York | 16-3-0 | 9 | NYS Class A State Champions |
| 5 | Staples High School | Westport, Connecticut | 20-1-1 | 5 | Class L State Champions, FCIAC Co-Champions |
| 6 | Sachem East High School | Farmingville, New York | 18-1-0 | 4 | NYS Class A State Semifinalist |
| 7 | Horace Greeley High School | Chappaqua, New York | 18-1-4 | 10 | NYS Class A State Runner-Up |
| 8 | Garden City High School | Garden City, New York | 15-4-0 | 6 | NYS Class B State Runner-Up |
| 9 | Darien High School | Darien, Connecticut | 19-2-1 | 11 | Class L State Runner-Up, FCIAC Co-Champions |
| 10 | Westminster School | Simsbury, Connecticut | 14-3-0 | 7 | NEPSAC A Semifinalist |
| 11 | Hotchkiss School | Lakeville, Connecticut | 11-4-1 | 12 | NEPSAC A Semifinalist |
| 12 | Mamaroneck High School | Mamaroneck, New York | 15-3-1 | 8 | Section 1 Class A Runner-Up |
| 13 | Guilford High School | Guilford, Connecticut | 21-0-0 | 17 | Class M State Champions, SCC Champions |
| 14 | New Canaan High School | New Canaan, Connecticut | 15-4-0 | OC | Class L State Quarterfinalist, FCIAC Semifinalist |
| 15 | Guilderland High School | Guilderland, New York | 11-8-0 | OC | NYS Class A State Quarterfinalist, Section 2 Class A Champions |
| 16 | Granby Memorial High School | Granby, Connecticut | 18-0-1 | OC | Class S State Champions, NCCC Champions |
| 17 | Norwalk High School | Norwalk, Connecticut | 15-4-0 | OC | Class L State Semifinalist, FCIAC Quarterfinalist |
| 18 | Penfield High School | Penfield, New York | 17-3-0 | NR | Class A State Semifinalist |
| 19 | East Greenwich High School | East Greenwich, Rhode Island | 15-1-1 | OC | Division I State Champions |
| 20 | Bronxville High School | Bronxville, New York | 17-3-2 | NR | Class C State Champions |
| OC | Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake High School | Burnt Hills, New York | 16-4-0 | 13 | NYS Class B Subregionals, Section 2 Class B Champions |
| OC | Holland Patent High School | Holland Patent, New York | 17-2-1 | NR | NYS Class B Regional Quarterfinalist |
| OC | Johnstown High School | Johnstown, New York | 20-1-0 | OC | NYS Class C State Runner-Up, Section 2 Class C Champions |
| OC | Pittsford-Mendon High School | Pittsford, New York | 18-1-1 | NR | Class B State Semifinalist |
| OC | Newtown High School | Sandy Hook, Connecticut | 18-2-0 | 14 | Class L State Quarterfinalist, SWC Semifinalist |
| OC | North Branford High School | North Branford, Connecticut | 20-1-1 | NR | Class S State Runner-Up |
| OC | North Kingstown High School | North Kingstown, Rhode Island | 15-3-0 | 20 | Division I State Runner-Up |
| OC | Ridgefield High School | Ridgefield, Connecticut | 15-5-0 | 19 | Class L State Semifinalist, FCIAC Semifinalist |
| OC | Shenendehowa High School | Clifton Park, New York | 13-3-0 | 15 | Section 2 Class A Runner-Up |
| OC | Smithtown East High School | St. James, New York | 13-4-0 | OC | Section XI Class A Semifinalist |
| OC | Vestal High School | Vestal, New York | 10-7-0 | NR | Class B State Semifinalist |
| OC | Williamsville East High School | East Amherst, New York | 18-2-0 | 18 | NYS Class B Quarterfinalist |
| OC | Williamsville North High School | Buffalo, New York | 16-2-0 | 16 | NYS Class A Quarterfinalist |
